Skip to main content
ORDER ONLINE FOR CONTACTLESS PAYMENT AND EASY SERVICE! - Easy online ordering and contactless payment for your convenience.
Write a Review, Win $500! Help guests by leaving a review of your favorite dishes. Be entered in a drawing to win $500 on 2/1.
My NY Pizza
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Order Online
  • About Us
  • Specials
  • Catering Packages
  • Party Trays
  • Contact
Menu

Menu

Become a VIPReceive updates on special events, new menu items, menu reviews, and more!

Menu

Like any of the items you ordered?

Thanks for visiting! We'd love to have your feedback.

APPETIZERS

GARLIC KNOTS
132056

GARLIC KNOTS

large order $6.49small order $3.99
 
92034

MOZZARELLA STICKS

large order $11.99small order $5.99
 
52003

GARLIC BREAD

small order $2.49large orger $3.49
 
82015

JALAPENO POPPERS

large order $14.99small order $7.99
 
$5.99

BREADSTICKS WITH MARINARA

31011
 
JALAPENO CHEESE BALLS
2490312

JALAPENO CHEESE BALLS

Small Order $6.49Large Order $10.49
 
103025

CHEESE BALLS

Small Order $4.49Large Order $8.49
 
40022

CHEESE BREAD

large order $4.49small order $3.29
 
$5.79

ONION RINGS

41003
 
$8.99

CHEESY BREADSTICKS WITH MARINARA

10001
 

Send to a friend

Share this menu with your friends ahead of time to get their mouths watering.

SALADS

Large (2-3 guests) | Family (5-7 guests)

GRILLED CHICKEN SALAD
10001

GRILLED CHICKEN SALAD

Grilled Chicken, Iceberg Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Olives, Cheese and Bell Peppers.

Individual $9.49Large $15.99Family $23.99
 
00000

CAESAR SALAD

Romaine Lettuce, Croutons & Parmesan Cheese

Individual $8.49Large $12.99Family $19.99
 
10001

CAESAR CHICKEN SALAD

Grilled Chicken, Romaine Lettuce, Croutons & Parmesan Cheese

Individual $9.49Large $15.99Family $23.99
 
22000

HOUSE SALAD

Iceberg Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Olives, Cheese and Bell Peppers

Individual $5.99Large $9.99Family $17.99
 
31002

ANTIPASTO Salad

All Ingredients from House Salad, then Topped with Turkey, Salami and Ham. Delicious!

Individual $9.99Large $17.99Family $25.99
 

Pizzas

Our Pies Are 31% BIGGER!
Our GIANT 28" Pizza Feeds an Army! (12-14 Persons)

Sizes:
GIANT 14" Slice | Large 16" | X-Large 18" | Jumbo 20" | GIANT 28"

GIANT 14" NY Slice [Our Personal Pizza]
14 reviews
3370422

GIANT 14" NY Slice [Our Personal Pizza]

NY Slice Cheese $5.29Toppings (Each) $0.80
 
1911035

CREATE YOUR OWN PIE

Select Whatever Toppings Your Creativity Desires!
[cost per each topping, cheese always included]

GIANT 14" NY Slice $0.80Large 16" (3-4 people) $1.50X-Large 18" (5-6 people) $2Jumbo 20" (7-8 people) $3GIANT 28" (12-14 people) $4
 
2080111

NEW YORK CHEESE PIE

Cheese is the New York Way!

14" NY Slice $5.29Large 16" (3-4 people) $15.99X-Large 18" (5-6 people) $17.99Jumbo 20" (7-8 people) $21.99GIANT 28" (12-14 people) $35.99
 

Toppings

Artichokes | Bacon Bits | Bell Peppers | Black Olives | Canadian Bacon | Chorizo | Fresh Basil | Fresh Garlic | Grilled Chicken | Ground Beef | Italian Sausage | Jalapeños | Meatballs | Mushrooms | Onions | Pepperoncini
| Pepperoni | Pineapple | Roasted Bell Peppers | Salami | Sausage | Spinach | Sun-Dried Tomatoes | Tomatoes

FAVORITE PIES

GIANT 14" NY Slice $7.69 | Large 16" (3-4 people) $21.99 | X-Large 18" (5-6 people) $25.99 | Jumbo 20" (7-8 people) $30.99 | GIANT 28" (12-14 people) $51.99

PASTRAMI
1 review
70007

PASTRAMI

Mustard, Pickles and Awesome Pastrami

 
20002

CHORIZO

Tasty Chorizo with Cilantro

 
83005

SPICY HAWAIIAN

Canadian Bacon, Pineapple, Jalapeños and Onions

 
00000

SRIRACHA CHICKEN PIZZA

Chicken Drizzled with SPICY Sriracha Sauce

 
40004

BUFFALO PIZZA

Grilled Chicken and Buffalo Sauce

 
40022

POPEYE

Spinach, Fresh Garlic with Olive Oil

 
114016

SUPREME

Pepperoni, Sausage, Bell Peppers, Mushrooms & Onions

 
20011

VEGETARIAN

Olives, Bell Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms and Tomatoes

 

AWESOME PIES

GIANT 14" NY Slice $8.99 | Large 16" (3-4 people) $26.99 | X-Large 18" (5-6 people) $30.99 | Jumbo 20" (7-8 people) $35.99 | GIANT 28" (12-14 people) $59.99

52012

ALL MEAT

Pepperoni, Sausage, Italian Sausage, Ham, Ground Beef, Canadian Bacon, Meatballs, Salami &
Bacon Bits

 
51004

CHICKEN ALFREDO

Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese with Special Creamy Alfredo Sauce.

 
10001

PHILLY STEAK

Philly Meat, Bell Peppers & Onions with Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese

 
53011

THE WORKS

Create your Dream Pizza by Selecting Ten (10) Toppings of your Choice, Cheese NOT included.

 
31002

WHITE PIZZA

Olive Oil, Fresh Garlic, and Three Cheeses: Provolone, Ricotta and Mozzarella Topped with Basil

 
THE FLORENTINE [NEW!]
42011

THE FLORENTINE [NEW!]

Creamy Alfredo Sauce with Spinach and Mushrooms

 
BBQ CHICKEN
2 reviews
61014

BBQ CHICKEN

Grilled Chicken, Red Onions, Bell Peppers, with BBQ Sauce & Whole Milk Mozzarella Cheese

 
00000

CHICKEN FAJITA

Fresh Garlic, Chicken, Red Onions, Green Bell Peppers & Provolone Cheese

 
30012

SPICY MEXICAN

Layer of Refried Beans with Tasty Chorizo, Meatballs, Bell Peppers, Onions, Jalapeños and SPECIAL Hot Sauce.

 
THE ARTISAN
11000

THE ARTISAN

Olive Oil, Fresh Garlic, Artichokes, Roasted Bell Peppers, Sun-Dried Tomatoes & Black Olives Drizzled with a Touch of Balsamic Vinaigrette

 
20011

MARGHERITA

Fresh Basil, Tomatoes, and Fresh Mozzarella Cheese

 

CALZONES

With Mozzarella and Ricotta Cheese and Secret Pizza Sauce the Brushed with Olive Oil and Seasonings. Pack with Flavor!

20011

NEW YORK CALZONE

With Mozzarella and Ricotta Cheese and Secret Pizza Sauce the Brushed with Olive Oil and Seasonings

Individual $7.50Large (3-4 people) $18.99X-Large (5-6 people) $22.99Jumbo (7-8 people) $27.99
 
32010

STROMBOLI

Sausage, Onions, Bell Peppers, Olives, Jalapeños, Mozzarella Cheese, Brushed with Olive Oil & Seasonings

individual $9.49Large 16" (3-4 people) $23.99X-Large (5-6 people) $27.99Jumbo (7-8 people) $33.99
 
CREATE YOUR OWN CALZONE
1 review
21010

CREATE YOUR OWN CALZONE

Pick 1 - 4 Ingredients
Additional Ingredients (each):
Individual: $1.25 | Large: $2.00 | X-Large: $3.00 | Jumbo: 
$4.00

Individual $9.49Large (3-4 people) $23.99X-Large (5-6 people) $27.99Jumbo (7-8 people) $32.99
 

WINGS

6 Pc $6.99 | 12 Pc $12.69 | 18 Pc $18.99 | 24 Pc $25.49

ORIGINAL BUFFALO
3 reviews
2040214

ORIGINAL BUFFALO

Mild, Hot, Extra Hot or Diablo

 
53002

GARLIC PARMESAN

 
30012

SWEET BBQ

 
20011

CHIPOTLE BBQ

 
20002

KICKIN' LEMON

 
SMOKIN' CAJUN DRY RUB - NEW!
10001

SMOKIN' CAJUN DRY RUB - NEW!

 
LEMON PEPPER
1 review
60015

LEMON PEPPER

 
107003

MEXICAN STYLE

 
41012

ASIAN RED (Hot!)

 
80026

MANGO HABANERO

 
00000

TAJIN

 
HAWAIIAN - NEW!
00000

HAWAIIAN - NEW!

 

PASTAS

All Pasta Dishes Include a Side Salad and Garlic Bread

SPAGHETTI with Marinara Sauce
00000

SPAGHETTI with Marinara Sauce

Lunch $9.49Dinner $10.99Kids Plate $5.99
 
00000

SPAGHETTI with Grilled Chicken

99

Lunch $10.49Dinner $13.49
 
10001

SPAGHETTI with Home Made Meatballs

Lunch $10.49Dinner $13.49
 
FETTUCCINE Alfredo
22000

FETTUCCINE Alfredo

Lunch $10.99Dinner $12.99
 
00000

SPAGHETTI with Meat Sauce

Lunch $10.49Dinner $13.49
 
21010

SPAGHETTI with Sausage

Lunch $10.49Dinner $13.49
 
00000

SPAGHETTI with Garlic, Olive Oil & Fresh Basil:

Lunch $9.99Dinner $11.99
 
30003

FETTUCCINE Alfredo with Chicken

Lunch $11.99Dinner $13.99
 

SANDWICHES

LUNCH Hour: Make it Combo: Chips or Fries for $1.00 Each.

ULTIMATE SUPREME PIZZA SANDWICH
1 review
10001

ULTIMATE SUPREME PIZZA SANDWICH

Packed with irresistible flavor! Delicious sandwich made with pizza dough, filled with a triple layer of cold cuts, then topped with sautéed onions, bell peppers, roast beef, mayo, mustard, avocado and provolone cheese. Oneof kind feast!

Feeds 12-14 Hungry People! $59.99
 
00000

HAM & CHEESE SANDWICH

healthy choice

6" $7.9912" $9.99
 
00000

TUNA SANDWICH

healthy choice

6" $7.9912" $9.99
 
00000

HAM & TURKEY SANDWICH

6" $9.8912" $11.49
 
00000

PASTRAMI SANDWICH

6" $9.8912" $11.49
 
00000

FULL-LENGTH SAUSAGE SANDWICH

6" $9.8912" $11.49
 
00000

CHICKEN CLUB SANDWICH

Chicken, Bell Peppers, Onions, Bacon and Garlic Sautéed, Then Topped with Melting Provolone Cheese

6" $9.9912" $11.99
 
AWESOME SANDWICH
1 review
00000

AWESOME SANDWICH

Mayo, Mustard the Stacked with Roast Beef, Turkey & Ham, Sautéed with Onions, Bell Peppers and Garlic, Then Topped with Melting Provolone Cheese. Try it Once and You Will Be Hooked!

6" $9.9912" $11.99
 
10001

VEGETARIAN SANDWICH

healthy choice

6" $7.9912" $9.99
 
10001

ROAST BEEF SANDWICH

6" $9.8912" $11.49
 
10010

MEATBALL SANDWICH

6" $9.8912" $11.49
 
00000

TURKEY SANDWICH

6" $9.8912" $11.49
 
30012

PHILLY CHEESE STEAK

Come On! It's a Philly Sandwich, Forget About It!

6" $9.9912" $11.99
 
00000

ITALIAN COMBO

Salami, Turkey and Ham, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Bell Peppers, Onions and Provolone Cheese.

6" $9.9912" $11.99
 

FRIES

$3.49

SIMPLE CUT FRIES

00000
 
$6.49

GARLIC FRIES

10001
 
$6.49

BACON CHEDDAR FRIES

10001
 
$3.99

SWEET POTATO FRIES

00000
 
PIZZA FRIES
1 review
$6.49

PIZZA FRIES

30003
 
$6.49

PASTRAMI FRIES

41003
 

BEER ON TAP

We Got You Covered with 12 Beers on Tap! $1 Bud Light Draft All Day, Everyday, 365 Days a Year! Limit 1 per customer, per visit, per day.

Modelo | Pacifico | Lagunitas IPA | Firestone 805 | Garage Mango | Wolf Pub IPA | Hangar 24 | Stella Artois | Bud Light

BOTTLED BEER

Variety Selection of Domestic and Imported Beers!

Imported Mexican Beers | Domestic | Premium

WINE

House Wine | Premium Wine

SOFT DRINKS

Coca Cola | Dr. Pepper | Lemonade | Fanta | Sprite | Ice Tea
2 Liter Soda – Carry-Out/Delivery Only.

Prices subject to change without notice. Delivery fees will apply.

Made with by Popmenu
My NY Pizza
Website Accessibility Assistance
Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window